Tuesday, April 24, 2018
Wardheer News
  • Book Shelf
  • Opinion

A Review of English-Maay Dictionary‏

Reviewed by Liban Ahmad 

Book: English-Maay Dictionary
Authors: Mohamed Haji Mukhtar and Omar Moalim Ahmed
Paperback: 213 pages
Publication date: July 2007

The Somali Maay  is one of the major dialects spoken in Somalia. Unlike the Maxaa  dialect,  which was chosen to become the standard dialect in Somalia in 1972, Maay dialect speakers have never enjoyed the privilege of seeing their  dialect  used in the public administration and as a medium of instruction.

English Maay DictionerySince 1991 a group of Maay-speaking intellectuals have  been  working hard to raise the profile of the dialect through meetings and seminars that culminated in the adoption of a less widely used orthography of Maay. Without their efforts the Somali Maay dictionary would not have seen the light of day.

As the name  of the dictionary shows lexicographers view Maay as one of the languages spoken in Somalia, a view to which Professor Abdalla Omar Mansur, a Somali linguist and lexicographer, disagrees.

Professor Mohamed Mukhtar and Omar Moalim Ahmed, who compiled and translated the first English-Maay  dictionary, look upon it  as ‘the first experiment exploring the roots of Maay language  and its relationship to other Somali dialects as well as the Kushitic family of languages in the Horn of Africa.’

Maay speakers assert theirs is a language different from the standard Maxaa dialect. ‘If Maxaa and Maay were  different languages a Maay speaker would not have understood what a Maxaa speaker had said’ argues Professor Mansur.

The dictionary will leave no one in doubt that Maay, despite the absence of a grammatical sketch of the dialect, is as a rich dialect as its Maxaa sibling. Mukhtar and Omar used a Maay orthography to translate  English entries of the bilingual dictionary but it is different from the orthography used to write the Maay version of the  Somali Draft Constitution.

The translation approach Mukhtar and Omar used is significant   due to the linguistic data it yields for the benefit  of Somali linguistics researchers. Familiarity with the standard Maxaa  grammar will go a long way to enable the researcher to appreciate similarities and differences between Maxaa and Maay dialects.

Grammatically, Maay and Maxaa dialects have a lot in common. Maay cluster prepositions  follow the same rules as those of Maxaa. When the impersonal pronoun  ly ( la ) is combined with the preposition ing (u) the result is ling  ( loo).

In Maay dialect  ing additionally is  a negative marker, the equivalent of aan of Maxaa dialect, as  the following example will illustrate: ‘masqang gal ing haayny’  ( absurd:  p.13) and ‘ ooftis ing haayny’ ( careless, p.41). If ling has no a variant spelling,  Maay  dialect grammar is  more complicated than standard Maxaa grammar:   the intensifier sy (si ) causes the impersonal pronoun ly ( la) to be assimilated with the preposition  ing (u) to produce  lyng as in ‘wal sy gef eh lyng etheegsythy (abuse: p.13) instead of ling as in ‘wal … [sy] feyli  ling deresi amy ling baary'( analyze, p.20).

Explaining why some Maay verbs are similar to Maxaa verbs in their imperative forms is beyond the scope of this review essay. The Maxaa verb  fiiri ( to look ) is fiiri in Maay but kari ( to cook ), which belongs to the same conjugation  group as fiiri,  becomes kariyow in Maay  ( to cook, p.55 ). If you want to say in Maay dialect ‘Cook food tomorrow!’, Professor Mukhtar and Omar expect you to say ‘Hung-gury kariyow barriyey!’

English-Maay dictionary  brings to our attention  phonological  complexities of the Somali Maay dialect, the second official language of the Federal Republic of Somalia. It is a major contribution to Somali Studies .

Liban Ahmad
Email: libahm@icloud.com

We welcome the submission of all articles for possible publication on WardheerNews.com. WardheerNews will only consider articles sent exclusively. Please email your article today . Opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of WardheerNews.

WardheerNew’s tolerance platform is engaging with diversity of opinion, political ideology and self-expression. Tolerance is a necessary ingredient for creativity and civility.Tolerance fuels tenacity and audacity.

WardheerNews waxay tixgelin gaara siinaysaa maqaaladaha sida gaarka ah loogu soo diro ee aan lagu daabicin goobo kale. Maqaalkani wuxuu ka turjumayaa aragtida Qoraaga loomana fasiran karo tan WardheerNews.

Copyright © 2018 WardheerNews, All rights reserved

One Response to “A Review of English-Maay Dictionary‏”

  1. moyu

    What a garbage! since when maay dialect of somalia became a language??? and what a waste of material by clannish sentment of the so called “prof” Mohamed Mukhtar

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.