Monday, July 23, 2018
Wardheer News
  • Opinion

Puntland on a Dangerous Precipice

By Mohamed Abshir

The Puntland State of Somalia is on a dangerous precipice. More than two and half years after taking charge of the most stable region of Somalia, President Abdiweli Gas policies have erupted into political revelries, jeopardizing the security and stability of the region. The absence of a democratic and accountable administration, widespread corruption, nepotism, clanism and the marginalization of Puntland stakeholders, have left many communities to believe that they have been intentionally left behind by the Garowe-based administration.

President Abdiwali M. Ali

The president, a fervent opponent of the 4.5 power-sharing formula, has been on the helm of a regional government that uses the same formula to monopolize political and economic powers in the hands of his clan. The formula places other non-Majeerteen clans into 0.5 designed to limit their political and economic participation. The policy undermines other clans and sub-clans in Puntland, leaving the state of the region as a Majeeteen entity.

The participation of all clans and sub-clans are critical to the security and stability of the region. At present, they are functionally excluded from important senior government positions as well as civil service positions that are reserved for the president’s clan. Those that do participate are coopted and influenced by the increasingly authoritarian regime and are routinely undermined by corrupt deputies who hold authority and only serve the president’s clan interests.

A case in point, the president recently indicated he would select the representatives of the Upper House of the Somali federal parliament for Puntland and the Sanaag and Sool regions, in a violation of the provisional federal constitution. Reports state that the plan gives Majeerteen eight seats, Sool two seats and Sanaag one seat. The selection takes away the Sanaag and Sool seats and gives extra seats to President’s clan. Without participation, the other communities are left with a few alternatives to address their grievances.

In addition, reports from international development agencies state that Puntland routinely blocks international development projects for Sanaag, Sool, Western Bari and Nugaal, especially in the areas inhabited by Dishiishe, Dhulbahante and Warsangeli as part of a plan to redirect development funds to Garowe, Galkacyo and Qardho. Since taking the helm in 2014, the Gas government has barred development projects for Sanaag and Sool regions and used the funds for developing Mudug. Still, Puntland claim the regions and works behind the scene to perpetuate a myth that the regions are disputed areas and dangerous for development agencies to operate. What is clear is that current and former Puntland administration have neither the desire, interest nor the will to help these communities.

The formation of Puntland in 1998 provided a vehicle for representation of all inhabitants of the region. Since that time, successive administrations have monopolized state resources, turning the region into family enclaves. These enclaves undermine federalism and the goals that established Puntland.

As result, political and community leaders from the Sanaag and Sool regions have formed interim administrations, the Northeast State of Somalia to represent their interests at the federal level and are seeking their share of development that is intentionally concentrated in and only benefit Garowe, Galkacyo and Qardho sub-clans.

The Gas administration has abandoned the appearance of democratic state, systematically marginalizing opposition leaders from Bari, Sool and Sanaag regions. The effect of these maneuvers have forced opposition leaders out of the government, further marginalizing clans and sub-clan interests. Frustrated leaders, including the vice president and the parliament, failed repeatedly to mount effective opposition to the regime.

Reports from the region indicated that  the administration is currently organizing a no confidence vote against opposition leaders including the vice president and previously removed the speaker of the parliament as well as threatened and/or arrested the free media. These undemocratic actions including the dismissal of ministers have sparked protests and potential showdown.

The opposition to President Gas’s failed administration has largely been peaceful, but exceptions, most notably a recent clan militia clash with Puntland forces that funded by the international community on June 23, 2016, demonstrate the potential for violence. The majority of opposition does not support violence; nevertheless, the discontent among opposition creates opportunity for al-Shabaab to expand their presence into Puntland, Sanaag and Sool.

The political fissures are the worst-case for Somalia. The targeting of opposition political figures as well as the free media is purely self-interested behavior by president, and it does nothing to advance the interests of Puntland. In fact, the discontent flames the marginalized communities and generates a threat to the regions security and stability and further undermines the president’s legitimacy.

According to western diplomats who cover Somalia, the international community is very concerned and is considering change in policy that sets conditions on assistance for Puntland.

The administration is advised to engage with opposition leaders and recognize their demands and address it in order to prevent political and security disintegration of the region. The longer these communities are left without an avenue of political participation, the more likely they may advocate for violent alternatives. If marginalization continues, it could potentially morph into a civil war that, in tandem with the insurgency, would have devastating effects on the Puntland, Somalia and the region.

Mohamed Abshir


We welcome the submission of all articles for possible publication on WardheerNews will only consider articles sent exclusively. Please email your article today . Opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of WardheerNews.

WardheerNew’s tolerance platform is engaging with diversity of opinion, political ideology and self-expression. Tolerance is a necessary ingredient for creativity and civility.Tolerance fuels tenacity and audacity.

WardheerNews waxay tixgelin gaara siinaysaa maqaaladaha sida gaarka ah loogu soo diro ee aan lagu daabicin goobo kale. Maqaalkani wuxuu ka turjumayaa aragtida Qoraaga loomana fasiran karo tan WardheerNews.

Copyright © 2018 WardheerNews, All rights reserved

6 Responses to “Puntland on a Dangerous Precipice”

  1. Faisal

    Abdiweli is so far the most incompetent leader of all of the Punland State leaders. He has consistently showed the luck of charisma, decisivenesss, and leadership. He only pits agaist his subordinate ministers and plays unwinnable endless tribal ball. He is now more a guest in Garowe and Bossaso. GALCAO is divided and unstable. The guy is complete failure and must be ashamed. At least his cousin is docile fat he-sheep willing please his masters. Abdiweli is like a betrayed and ill ex-gangester, often decrying of not being ignored and satisfied about stamped political schemes.

  2. Wiil Waal

    The problem is not Mr. Gas per se. The degeneration started with Mr. Yusuf and Puntland has been in free fall ever since. Puntland’s name has now become synonymous with the one sub clan whose sole interest it serves. One may need to compare the starkly different treatments between SSC regions which are under relentless attack every day (notwithstanding the behavior of its people some of whom willingly serve the aggressor) and Galkacyo. Some of us had high hopes that Mr. Gas would be different and correct things, but, unfortunaltely, he is not faring better than his predecessors. In fact, he doubled down in the pursuit of the interest of his sub clan.

  3. A.muse

    The man seems to have confused with his previous role as prime minister versus his current role as state president. First thing in assuming in any job is to seek understanding one’s job description, unfortunately he miserably failed to comprehend that. Moreover, when he assumed his current role, I was under the impression that he would establish new local parties and institute a new system of transparency and equity- thinking that his accumulated knowledge over years will translate into local beneficiary and set a replicated example for the rest of our hapless country. Again, he miserably failed for all Somalis, let alone local diverse Puntland constituencies. It is all about leadership at the end of the day!

  4. Mohamed Yare

    I only hear what Mr. Gaas is against, but I don’t know what he is for. He only proposed one idea: a power sharing based on area square mile/ tribal . I don’t know if any other country uses this “model” not to mention he himself is sitting on a 4.5 formula as the head of PL. That said, I still believe people do best when they solve their own problems locally. Self-governess is the way to go. The progress may be slow, but people are learning from it. PL is a good example this; Cadde Muse was a one term president and so as Faroole that shows people are still searching for a quality leadership.

  5. Runsheeg Xaqaani

    Few facts blended with lot of lies. PL president is not in a position to block aid or development projects directed to any parts of Puntland. Donors have their own agenda and Somalis from Federal President to district Mayors are simply puppets or bread seekers who accept every penny that comes out from donors’ pocket, just to create jobs for unemployed youth or to feed malnourished population.Find other reason to justify why Aid funds are not channeled to Sool and Sanaag.

  6. Dablariday

    I can’t explain why some of the Puntland intellectuals are angry about President Abdiweli M. A Gas and dislike or hate him with passion, and why it has little to do with his actions and policies!?? …To say our president has his hands full is an understatement. But his leadership style is ideally suited for times such as these. He displays a presence that I would define as “calm assertiveness
    I think some of the Puntland intellectuals didn’t like Dr. Abdiweli because he seems always to be talking about things in an intellectual, and professorial style…. In my humble opinion Dr. Abdiweli Ali had demonstrated a true leadership style, showing the perseverance to accomplish his campaigns goals, regardless of the seemingly insurmountable obstacles. The President displayed a confident calmness when he was under stress, maintaining traits through good times and bad times and he continually focused on the hard political issues regardless of the situation……
    Who among us would like to be president of the PL in these turbulent times and Post Civil war transitions…? No One. I thought so. Well, it is my belief that we have the right man at the right time in the right place (Villa Growe).

    Right now we need a cool, calm, collected leader that does not fly off the handle, make panicky and risky decisions off the cuff, or rush into volatile situations with no thought to the consequences. Just because his style is very different from his predecessor (Warlords) doesn’t mean he is not an effective PL leader. In fact, it’s just the opposite….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.